Analysis & Comment > Bond of the Week
Bond of the Week Archive
Bond of the Week: 10 September 2010
Yorkshire BS 13.5% 2025: 10 September 2010
I last looked at the Yorkshire 13.5% 2025 contingent convertibles in February. Then, the Yorkshire and Chelsea building societies were in the throws of a shotgun marriage, with the gruff no-nonsense northerner rescuing its southern counterpart. During this bail-out and refinancing process, the holders of PIBS and other subordinated debt carried most of the pain, with holders of such bonds forced to take a 50% "haircut" on their investment in order to boost the capital of the newly-merged society. Out of this deal came a new security, the Yorkshire Building Society 13.5% 2025.
This instrument is what is known as a "contingent convertible". Building societies can not issue equity, so in order to improve their capital ratios, the YBS and its bankers launched what is effectively a hybrid bond. The key feature of the contingent convertible is this - if the building society’s tier one capital falls below 5%, the bond holders will suffer a forced conversion to "PPDS" - profit participating deferred shares. Should this event happen, it would not be a happy one for the bond holders. Dividend payments for PPDS are related to the profits of the company and are discretionary. Thus the risk associated with this instrument is higher than that on a conventional bond.
The details of the security are as follows:
Since the launch of the new amalgamated issue, the market price initially ticked up into the mid-twenties, but has declined since currently languishing in the ’teens, considerably underperforming its peers. Why might this be so? I would suggest that the fundamentals for the security are positive. Yorkshire’s half-year results, released in June (click here to download), showed the Society swinging back into the black with core operating profits at £53 million. The balance sheet looks sensible with member savings on the increase, supporting 97% of loans. Capital ratios are strong with core tier one at 11.8%, slightly up from the 11.1% seen last year.
I suspect that the poor price performance may be related to the lack of visibility of this security. Unlike most PIBS or preference shares, the Yorkshire bond lacks a LSE quote and is rarely featured on broker’s lists or in the online chatrooms favoured by enthusiasts of these instruments.
The market price of the security is currently in the mid-teens. At 115, the yield to maturity is 11.4% somewhat higher than the yields offered by the majority of PIBS, preference shares and ECNs. Another advantage of the new security is the low minimum size. The refinancing deal needed to accommodate the previous "shapes" of the precursor securities; £50,000 for the Yorkshire PIBS and £1,000 for the Chelsea subordinated bonds. After factoring in a 50% "haircut" on the deal this left the new bond with a £500 minimum denomination. This smaller size is an extremely useful side effect of the deal, enabling private investors to scale their purchases according to the size of their portfolios.
My view: The UK PIBS, preference share and subordinated financial sector has performed strongly this year, and in general offers rather lower yields, and thus less value, than was seen at back in February. The Yorkshire 13.5% 2025 has lagged this rally and is one of the few instruments still offering a double-digit yield.
The 11.4% yield is attractive and in my view adequate compensation for the risk, particularly in view of the solid results from the newly merged society. I view the bond as a buy, and I intend to purchase a holding for the www.fixedincomeinvestor.co.uk model portfolio. However, I would stress the point that this bond should be held as part of diversified portfiolio. This is particularly important for subordinated or hybrid instruments, where the risk of default or other credit-driven events is higher than a conventional bond. Investors should also be aware that the relatively poor transparency/liquidity situation may mean that liquidating the security ahead of the redemption date may be difficult, particularly in adverse market conditions.
Fixed Income Investor is a division of Stockcube Research Ltd which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority. The research provided by Stockcube on the Website (and any other Stockcube website) is provided solely to enable investors to make their own investment decisions and does not constitute personal investment recommendations. No recommendations are made directly or indirectly by Stockcube as to the merits or suitability of any investment decision or transaction which may result directly or indirectly from having viewed the investment research on the Website or having received it by email. Investors are therefore urged to seek independent financial advice if they are in any doubt. The value of investments and the income derived from them can go down as well as up, and the investor may not get back the full amount originally invested.
Bonds, as with all investments, are subject to price volatility and in the event of a default an investor may lose some or all of his or her original investment. This site also contains references to derivatives. These are particularly high risk, high reward investment instruments and an investor may lose more than his initial margin requirement. Some foreign currency instruments are also featured and if an investor decides to acquire any investment denominated in a currency different from the his or her own, the investor should note that changes in foreign exchange rates may have an adverse effect on the value, price and income of the investment in the base currency.
None of the services provided as a result of this agreement constitutes a personal recommendation to invest from Stockcube and no service should be construed as such. For the avoidance of doubt, where the word “recommendation” is used elsewhere in these terms it does not refer to a personal recommendation, unless this is explicitly stated. The investments described by or in the services are not suitable for all investors. Investors who have any doubt about whether particular investments are suitable for them should contact an independent financial adviser.
These services do not include personal investment recommendations from Stockcube and should not be construed as such. Stockcube may, at its discretion, provide information, advice, recommendations and research to subscribers from time to time on its own initiative or advise subscribers of other services available. Stockcube will be under no obligation to provide on-going advice in relation to financial instruments covered on this website.